2009 Housing News

Harbor Lights Condo
Harbor Lights Condos

Isle luxury projects in limbo over financing
Keaka, Everett Dowling’s development company, was at the Maui Planning Commission last week to seek an amendment to permits for its Maluaka project to drastically downsize the project from 71 luxury condominiums to 13 lots plus recreational facilities. The commission favored it, also praising Dowling for seeking LEED "green" certification on his development.
Demand for luxury housing is down, but it appears that lack of financing is an even greater impediment to developments and redevelopments along Maui’s golden shores.

The efforts to preserve Honolua Bay and Lipoa Point
Read three articles on efforts by local citizens and elected
officials to preserve land at Honolua Bay and Lipoa Point from luxury
home development.

Where is Maui’s Affordable Housing?
In less than three years, residents have witnessed the average
price of a single-family home climb from $375,000 to $665,000 –
prompting many to abandon dreams of owning a home.

Council reviews Residential Workforce Housing Act
The Public Services Committee began its required review of the
legislation crafted to increase affordable housing on Maui. Amendments
may be proposed by committee members that will require approval before
the full Council.

State set to review Pu’unani proposal
Developers of Pu’unani will need district changes approved by the
state Land Use Commission and new zoning from the Maui County Planning
Commission and County Council before the 208-acre project gets under
way.The new subdivision would build 754 units in Wailuku, south of the
corner of Honoapiilani Highway and Kuikahi Drive.

Residential Workforce Housing Act review begins
The Public Services Committee will begin this week reviewing 30
pages of detailed administrative rules that expand on the Residential
Workforce Housing Act. The two-year old legislation was created to
require new subdivisions to provide 40 percent to 50 percent of homes
at a price affordable for local residents.

luxury oceanview development
Lots of luxury vacation houses
not so many affordable homes

116-unit housing project for seniors in Kula proposed
An architect who has specialized in high-quality resort residential
projects, Clayton Nishikawa, is proposing to build a 116-unit senior
housing project on Lower Kula Road. Kula Meadowood would include 70
affordable units and 46 market-priced units in what he described as an
age-in-place, independent-living subdivision on 85 acres of former
pineapple fields just south of Kula 200. Nishikawa said he is trying to
get a reading on community support for the project, which has not been
included in urban growth boundaries proposed for the county’s General
Plan. As such, it would likely not be endorsed by the county Planning
Department.

Maui Land & Pine’s Pulelehua  project
Developer is seeking a Community Plan Amendment and a change in zoning

Victorino proposes resolution seeking fairness for TVR operators
Operators
of transient vacation rentals who have been "caught in legal limbo"
because of the County’s confusing and contradictory enforcement
policies shouldn’t be punished, Maui County Councilmember Michael
Victorino said today. Victorino has proposed a resolution calling on
the County Administration to suspend enforcement actions against TVR
operators until the Council has had a chance to review and enact
legislation currently pending before the Council’s Planning Committee.
The Committee isn’t expected to review the bills submitted by the
Department of Planning and the planning commissions until June.

Maalaea project’s EIS ready for review
The developers of a proposed 949-unit residential community at
Maalaea have submitted their draft environmental impact study for
public comment. The $400 million Maalaea Mauka would cover 257 acres of
former sugar cane land classified by the state and county as
agricultural. The project would be mix of single- and multifamily
homes, townhouses, rental apartments and affordable housing for
seniors. Maalaea Mauka would also include park land and a community
center, according to the document issued Dec. 8.
(see also: 1,000-home Hawaii subdivision planned)

Planned Maui Lani complex in question
A Maui Lani official said that she is unsure if the company will be
able to build a proposed 72-unit affordable rental complex after a
County Council committee imposed additional conditions on the project.
The committee wants Maui Lani to lengthen the time that at least half
of the units have to be rented to families earning below 80 percent of
the median income level.
Maui Lani had proposed it would keep rents in the 80 percent and below
median income level ($55,920 for a family of four) for 15 years, but
would then make the units available for sale or rent to the "gap" group
– those making 120 percent to 160 percent of the median income ($83,880
to $111,840) for an additional 10 years.

Councilors find housing details hard to swallow
With the support of county administration housing officials, Maui Lani
Partners is using the state’s fast-track housing law to shorten
government reviews of a 72-unit low-income rental complex planned on
2.5 acres next to Pomaika’i Elementary School. Council members can
accept the project as proposed, modify it with the developer’s consent
or reject it within 45 days of the proposal’s submission on Aug. 24.

Affordable housing mandate added to Honua’ula’s list
Council
Member Michelle Anderson proposed that Honua’ula be required to develop
250 affordable units offsite immediately after the County Council
approves zoning for the project. She also wants the developers to
donate a park as a condition for the project approvals.

Zoning request stalled by neighbors’ protests
Haiku residents up in arms about a proposed Kokomo subdivision
petitioned the Maui Planning Commission to prevent a zoning change that
would allow landowner Ron Serle to create a 10-lot rural subdivision in
the area. According to Serle and his planning consultants, however, the
land has been designated for rural use since 1983 in the Paia-Haiku
Community Plan.

Developer: Land to stay agricultural
The developer of an 1,800-acre agricultural subdivision in lower Kula
said the plan is aimed at keeping the former pineapple land in
agricultural use. Farmers and residents in the area were not convinced
when representatives of Kula 1800 Investment Partners LLC presented the
plans at a special meeting of the Kula Community Association. Waiakoa
Ranch would have 86 large lots on the former pineapple and pasturelands
running from Pulehu to Naalae Road below Kula Highway. Lot sizes will
range from 6 to 40 acres, with one large remnant parcel of 323 acres
available for sale or lease.

A&B files for new residential project in Kihei
A&B Properties is proposing long-range residential development of
93 acres in North Kihei. A&B Vice President Grant Chun said
A&B’s petition for land reclassification from agricultural to urban
is the "first step in a long process" toward development of nearly 68
acres of multifamily units, 25 acres of single-family residences and
1.4 acres of commercial space. The amount of acreage eyed for the
project would be enough room for about 600 multifamily and
single-family units, he said.

Na HALE O Maui offers hope to future homeowners with a radical new approach to affordable housing
Under the old rules of affordability, people on Maui earning the median
income shouldn’t move into a home that costs more than about
$160,000-to do otherwise is to spend far too much each month on
mortgage payments, leaving nothing for savings. But for the last few
years it’s been impossible to find a house for even twice that amount
anywhere on the island that’s fit for human habitation.

Sustainable communities will benefit all
The sustainable communities we envision are affordable and welcoming –
free from financial or physical barriers preventing anyone from
entering. In Hawaii, developers must also respect and preserve the
beauty of our islands by including open space and recycling waste
instead of diverting it to landfills. And our best communities will
help reduce Hawaii’s dependence on imported fuels by generating half of
their power on-site.

Council’s vacation rental bill shelved
A long-debated bill to regulate vacation rentals was killed Thursday by
the County Council Planning Committee, after committee members agreed
the proposal on the table just didn’t have enough community support.
The proposed bill sought to establish standards and policies for
vacation rentals and bed-and-breakfasts, and to clarify and streamline
permitting procedures. But it received an unenthusiastic response from
the county Planning Department and the Maui, Molokai and Lanai planning
commissions. 02.16.07

Ranch a No Show at Commission Meeting
The absence of Molokai Ranch along with the Ranch’s published threat to
bring its "Doomsday" plan down on the community if its controversial
La’au development plan is not approved were some of the hot topics
covered at the Molokai Planning Commission’s January 30 evening meeting
at Kaunakakai School. 02.08.07

LUC approves Hale Mua project
The Hale Mua affordable housing project in Waiehu was close to crashing
and burning Friday, but at the last minute – actually, an hour past the
last minute – it won the Land Use Commission boundary amendment it
needs to keep moving. Maybe. The commission passed a version different
from the proposal that the County Council passed in 2005 under the
state’s 201G fast-track process for affordable housing projects. The
changes are potentially substantive enough to force developer Sterling
Kim back to an earlier stage in the authorization sequence. He
indicated that his costs are mounting so quickly that more delays could
kill the project. 01.20.07

Tavares asks for help with housing, energy, water
Mayor Charmaine Tavares gave a low-key pitch to legislators on state
money committees Tuesday, saying housing and renewable energy programs
would be the county’s top priorities in the coming years. In contrast
with her predecessor, former Mayor Alan Arakawa, who often read lengthy
and detailed testimony in his annual appeal to state lawmakers, Tavares
spoke off the cuff and focused on a few key issues, noting she was in
just her 10th working day on the job and was still "sifting through the
facts" left to her when she took office. 01.17.07

Council Over-rides Arakawa Veto -Passes Workforce Housing Ordinance
A new residential work force housing policy became law Tuesday after
the Maui County Council unanimously overrode a veto by Mayor Alan
Arakawa. "This is the win-win situation that we all strive for," said
Housing Chairman Danny Mateo, who got in the last word at a special
meeting held Tuesday in Council Chambers to override the mayor’s veto.
Members voting to override included Mayor-elect Charmaine Tavares, who
will be responsible for implementing the new law when she takes office
Jan. 2. She was joined by Council Chairman Riki Hokama and Council
Members Michelle Anderson, Bob Carroll, Jo Anne Johnson, Dain Kane and
Mateo. Council Members Mike Molina and Joe Pontanilla were excused. 12.06.06

Mayor Arakawa vetos Workforce Housing Bill
As promised, Mayor Alan Arakawa vetoed a residential work force housing
policy Friday that proposed requiring as much as 50 percent affordable
units in future developments. 11.25.06

Council approves Workforce Housing policy
The Maui County Council passed the Residential Workforce Housing Policy
that would set strict new requirements for developers to build
affordable homes. Mayor Alan Arakawa planned to veto the bill, saying
it would do more to hurt the housing market than help. But the
council’s unanimous vote indicated more than enough support to override
an Arakawa veto. Council members said the policy would be an important
first step in providing more housing for local residents and said
warnings about the policy just came from developers protecting their
business interests. 11.04.06

Planning commission OK’s Dowling’s Keaka project
The pros outnumbered the cons 5-2 when the commission voted Tuesday on
a special management area permit and special accessory use permit for
the $220 million project down the coastline from the Maui Prince Hotel. 11.18.06

Project district OK’d for Kapalua Mauka
A deadlock in the Maui Planning Commission broke Tuesday afternoon,
giving Maui Land & Pineapple Co. approval for its plans to build
multimillion-dollar homes and a new private golf course at the Kapalua
Resort. The development, which earlier this year had received project
district zoning approval from the County Council, also was seeking a
special management area use permit for off-site infrastructure
improvements to support Kapalua Mauka. 11.18.06

Voters approve affordable housing fund
Maui voters adopted a mandate for Maui County to set aside 2 percent of
real property tax revenues for an affordable housing fund in Tuesday’s
county special election. Along with an affordable housing policy
approved last week by the council, Council Housing Chairman Danny Mateo
said the county will be moving to establish affordable housing for the
community. 11.08.06

Sessions permit the people’s input on future of Maui’s land
About six months ago, Housing for the Local Person concluded that the
County Council was hearing a lot from real estate developers through
their lobbyists and from other interested parties but not directly from
the common man and woman. HLP felt that it was paramount that the
County Council heard from the common man and woman of Maui because they
would be the primary beneficiaries of this new law. So we decided to
have talk story sessions throughout Maui. 07.12.06

This New HouseMaui Tomorrow’s plans to revolutionize affordable housing
"We decided at Maui Tomorrow that we would come up with a model that
would work for Maui," said Richard Michaels, the group’s Affordably
Housing Committee chairman. Michaels said he and his wife became
convinced of the need to overhaul the affordable housing process while
attending Makena development hearings last year. 03.24.05

We need an effective Affordable Housing Policy and authority for Maui County
Truly affordable – what has been called ‘real’ housing – is vital to
stop the exodus of long term residents and locals to the mainland. More
Hawaiians now live on the mainland than here in Hawaii.

Developer outlines ‘green’ subdivision planned for Kihei
Speaking for Maui Tomorrow, Ron Sturtz has been before the Maui
Planning Commission "countless times," usually voicing more or less
criticism of other people’s developments. Tuesday, he stood up to speak
for himself as a developer of a 65-lot residential project in Kihei.
"I’ve been to countless hearings, and we listened to what you say," he
said of his Liloa Village plans. 02.10.05

Mayor promises water for affordable housing project
Mayor Alan Arakawa said Tuesday that he has assured developer Jesse
Spencer that there will be water available for Spencer’s planned
100-acre affordable housing project in Waikapu. After already expending
several thousand dollars on preliminary studies for the project,
Spencer said he needed to know for sure that he will be able to proceed
as planned through a "fast-track" process to build on the agricultural
land. 08.07.03